2021年2月22日 · The Strange Man will offer him two paths: a choice of valuing life or killing for his own gain. He'll warn him that attempting to make amends later in life will ultimately fail to save his soul. Marston will dismiss the odd man's foolish rambling, make his first kill, and earn a measly few bucks for it, not knowing that he so frivolously ...

2023年3月9日 · In the final interaction between John and the strange man John says to tell him his name or he won't be responsible for his actions with the strange man thanks says oh yes you will, this is a nice spot, the spot they are at is where jack will later bury John, as the strange man walks away John say damn you in which the stranger says that many ...

2023年4月25日 · 127 votes, 21 comments. true. i really enjoyed reading this and i think it makes a lot of sense, im impressed that anyone can put all this together lol. the way john is shot 21 times and he shoots the strange man 3 times, idk, either that is a very specific coincidence but to me the number of times john is shot, i feel like rockstar wouldn't skip on an opportunity by making it …

2018年11月14日 · In RDR1 the Strange man tells John that he’s “forgotten far more important people than me” after talking about a girl called Heidi Dutch killed on the ferry robbery, I take this as a way of saying “you’ve killed so many people without thought you’ve forgotten about your own death and the consequences of dying” I’m very open now ...

2021年11月22日 · The strange man, I know his identity. He's Cain from the bible. He is doomed to walk the earth for eternity, marked by god so that all will recognize him. After killing his brother Abel, Cain is marked by God, so that all will recognize him, and any who do him harm will have vengeance enacted upon them 7 times over.

2024年5月6日 · The Strange man is the most compelling character in rockstar games. He is a mysterious man who is believed to be possibly many entities, depending on interpretation. The most common theory is that he is the grim reaper/death himself, this is do to the testing of John’s morality soon before his death and the fact he references himself as “An ...

2022年2月27日 · I truly think that the strange man is the grim reaper himself 1 he always wears black 2 he says he's a personification of death 3 he always knows where John is 4 only John can see the painting of the strange man meaning he is the only one who is able to see him 5 the reason he can't be killed by John and how he can disappear and I like to ...

2021年8月30日 · So, a recent Strange Man video was published onto this subreddit by a fellow member and made some claims about the link between an old GTA:O tattoo, and the island of Guarma. This video was subsequently removed and a moderator replied to my comment claiming the video was clickbait.

2019年7月19日 · Also wanted to mention, that in fitting with the Redemption motif of the games, I believe the Strange Man is also trying to atone for past mistakes, thus redeeming himself to “God” Edit: The Strange Man is on the Gold Pocket Watch! There is something weird in the watch though. The Roman numeral for IV(4) looks like this IIII. UPDATE!

So when the strange man says, “you’ve forgotten far more important people than me.” There is no way he could be referencing Arthur as he was not created yet. Rockstar was obviously referencing someone else. That is an interesting theory though. Btw, pay attention to the strange man’s dialogue. I like to think he is God, or the Devil.