Instead, Amish potato salad is typically made with a rich, luscious blend of oil, egg yolks, vinegar, and spices — ingredients you whisk together yourself to make a classic homemade mayonnaise.

Milo Miller (@floridaboy920), an ex-Amish reality TV star, recently shared his four-ingredient recipe for “Amish cough syrup” on TikTok, where it’s already racked up over 889,000 views.